Using Dialogue Tags Correctly

Showing What a Character Says Instead of Telling

Jul 12, 2009 Judith Bakley

The use of dialogue tags should be kept to a minimum. Keep in mind that it's always better to avoid adding them to prevent misuse.

There are a few major pet peeves for all editors. One of them is the use of dialogue tags. What is a dialogue tag? It is a way of letting the reader know who is speaking; for instance “he said”, “she asked” or “the girl hissed”. Though it is easier to use these every time a character speaks, it is not necessarily the best way to do it. There are better ways of doing the same thing.

Use no More Than One Dialogue Tag per Paragraph

One major thing to keep in mind is that once a character has been identified as speaking, further dialogue tags are unnecessary. To add more is not only redundant but they can become obstacles to the reader, road bumps if you will. Writing should always flow, and too much repetitiveness can lose your reader.

“I walked home alone the other night,” Marie stated, rubbing her cold arms. “It was very dark, and I was scared,” she added, shivering at the memory.

There should be no more than one tag for each dialogue paragraph. Here is a better way to write the above.

“I walked home alone the other night,” Marie stated, rubbing her cold arms. “It was very dark, and I was scared.” She shivered at the memory.

Of course not using dialogue tags at all is the best way to write.

“I walked home alone the other night.” Marie rubbed her cold arms. “It was very dark, and I was scared.” She shivered at the memory.

If Words are Breathed, There Would be no Sound

Compare the first and last dialogue paragraphs to judge for yourself, which reads better. Using the last example also prevents making the mistake of using an incorrect method of speech. These incorrect tags include breathed and shrugged (to name only a few). You cannot breathe or shrug a word. Most times ending the dialogue and starting a new sentence can fix them.

Wrong: “I love you,” she breathed into his mouth.

Better: “I love you.” She breathed into his mouth.

The first sentence states she breathed the words into his mouth, which is an incorrect tag. The second states she said the words and then breathed into his mouth, which is grammatically correct. If that changes the intent, it can be stated as follows:

Best: “I love you.” The words floated on her breath into his open mouth.

The above keeps the correct intent without using the incorrect dialogue tag. Just keep in mind it’s always better to avoid using dialogue tags to prevent using them wrong.

The copyright of the article Using Dialogue Tags Correctly in Writing Fiction is owned by Judith Bakley. Permission to republish Using Dialogue Tags Correctly in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
How to Use Dialogue Tags, Stock Photo
How to Use Dialogue Tags
   
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 3+10?

Comments

Jul 13, 2009 3:27 AM
Garridon :
Good advice, though I'm surprised you didn't mention the most common mistake of all---the silly ones (i.e., he ejaculated, she pontificated). I've seen writers who collect these words. They come to a message board and say they're running out, post a long list, and and ask for more. Those are distracting at best, and sometimes unintentially funny--and three times worse when used for every bit of dialogue. Yikes! My rule of thumb is to use only the ones that come naturally, so I end up with about four or five total. But the more I write, the less I find that I need even those. Sometimes it isn't clear who is speaking, and an action tag feels excessive. That's when I slip something like "West said" in.

Linda Adams
http://www.linda-adams.com
Jul 13, 2009 7:19 AM
Judith Bakley :
Thanks for the comment,Linda! I guess I didn't mention those since I don't use them (and I wanted to keep the article simple). But thank you for bringing them up. I can't imagine anyone seriously using ejaculated as speech, but I know they do. It IS unintentionally funny!

Judith
2 Comments